· 6 min read · Dawn Lith Advisory
Where assessments fall short
The most common weakness is a template completed without data. Risk ratings are asserted, not derived. The second is a failure to separate inherent risk from residual risk, so there is no visible account of what controls achieve.
Others follow: no consideration of the national risk assessment, no link from the assessment to the customer risk model, and no evidence that senior management read or approved it.
What good looks like
A defensible assessment starts with a written methodology. It uses the firm's own data on customers, products, geographies and channels. It scores inherent risk, evaluates controls on evidence and arrives at residual risk by a method anyone can follow.
Most importantly, it changes something. If the assessment finds higher risk in a product or corridor, controls, resourcing or appetite should move in response.